Founder’s Journal
A transparent record of decisions
Each entry captures a decision made during founding — what was decided, why, what alternatives were considered, what’s been left open. The Founder’s Backlog at the bottom collects questions deliberately deferred to the appropriate governing body once it exists.
Entries
- Entry 001Thu Apr 23 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)URL Structure — Paths, Not SubdomainsOLN uses path-based URLs for Franchises and canonical entities. Subdomains are reserved for a future graduation escape hatch.Decided
- Entry 002Thu Apr 23 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)Canonical Entity Architecture — Dual SurfaceCanonical entities exist at two URLs serving two query intents — Network (who/what is X?) and Franchise (X in this world).Decided (with one deferred parameter)
- Entry 003Thu Apr 23 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)Franchise Model — Unitary Default with Explicit ForkingMost Franchises are singular; forking exists as a first-class explicit feature for irreconcilable governance disputes.Partially decided; key parameters deferred to community
- Entry 004Sat Apr 25 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)Network Revenue WaterfallNetwork-level revenue flows through a transparent waterfall: infrastructure, R&D pool, Franchise distribution, then excess governed by Need-vs-Greed.Decided in principle; specific percentages deferred to constitutional drafting
- Entry 005Sat Apr 25 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)Contributor Ad SovereigntyContributors earn the right to choose their ad experience — Ad-Free or voluntary Patron Mode — through accumulated contribution.Decided in principle; earning thresholds deferred
- Entry 006Sat Apr 25 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)Acquisition Constitutional PrincipleOLN may only acquire if a clear, public before-and-after case shows the platform becomes structurally stronger — a constitutional commitment, not policy.Decided in principle; constitutional language and unwind mechanics open
- Entry 007Sun Apr 26 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)OLN / LoreDoor Brand ArchitectureOpen Lore Network is the entity, mission, and governance layer. LoreDoor is the consumer-facing brand the platform operates under.Decided
- Entry 008Sun Apr 26 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)HellaThis as Sister ProductHellaThis operates as a sister product under the OLN Foundation umbrella, powered by OLN's contributor-curated Fact graph.Decided in principle; structural details open
- Entry 009Sun Apr 26 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)Memory Alpha Migration via Structured ExtractionMemory Alpha is the launch Franchise. Migration converts wikitext to structured Facts and OLN-native page templates — no wikitext support.Decided in principle; pipeline architecture open
- Entry 010Sun Apr 26 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)LoreLines as Third Contribution SurfaceOLN has three first-class contribution surfaces, not two: Commons, Home, and LoreLines — the structured interpretive graph layer.Decided in principle; governance specifics open
- Entry 011Sun Apr 26 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)No Founder Exception — Power Applies to All EquallyAll governance Power — including founders — is earned through ongoing contribution. No member holds permanent governance authority by virtue of position alone.Decided as constitutional principle
- Entry 012Sun Apr 26 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)Dilution, Not DecayPower earned in OLN is permanent but is measured as a share of total Power, which grows with the platform — sustained influence requires sustained contribution.Decided as governance mechanic
- Entry 013Sun Apr 26 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)Locked-Power + Return Voting MechanismVoting locks Power for a cycle; conviction multipliers translate passion into influence. Locked Power returns regardless of outcome.Decided as governance mechanic; parameters deferred
- Entry 014Sun Apr 26 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)Constitutional Amendment Process — Protection from TakeoverConstitutional changes require stacked supermajority + quadratic voting + cooldown + Foundation board ratification — a layered defense against capture.Decided as constitutional principle; specific thresholds deferred
- Entry 015Tue Apr 28 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)Pre-Launch Engagement — Reactions and Founder's CreditsJournal and Register entries will surface reader reactions (anonymous +1/-1 acceptable; registered viewers preferred). Registered users will accrue credits during the pre-launch phase, at a rate intentionally not pre-committed.Decided in principle; operational specifics deferred to G-036 and G-037
- Entry 016Tue Apr 28 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)Public Roadmap and Open-Source GatewayOLN will publish a public roadmap with project-level work items, allow viewers to signal priority, and treat completed work — including the founders' own time — as credit-earning at a single denomination. Calibration of credit values and the contribution-acceptance flow are deliberately open.Decided in principle; operational specifics deferred to G-038
- Entry 0172026-04-28Retroactive roadmap captureDecided and applied
- Entry 0192026-05-08Provider-seeded cold-start via provisional-imported stateImported facts enter the graph in a new provisional-imported lifecycle state — auto-attributed to provider, no Credits, open to validate/dispute on day one.Decided
- Entry 0202026-05-08Citation strength tiers (ratifies G2)Four-tier citation strength model. Tier-1 and tier-2 citations modify v_for weight in the consensus formula; specific multipliers TBD.Decided
- Entry 0212026-05-08Ingest Studio as first-class surfaceHI-in-the-loop ingest layer with versioned mappings, multi-dimensional re-run, and drift detection. AI proposes; humans approve; code enforces — no auto-approval threshold.Decided
- Entry 0222026-05-08AI/ML role split — probabilistic batch vs runtime scoring vs deterministic rulesLLMs handle offline batched cognitive work; classical ML handles runtime scoring; rules and code own everything load-bearing for governance. Embeddings bridge the layers.Decided
- Entry 0232026-05-08Storage architecture — Postgres-firstTriple store on Postgres with Apache AGE and pgvector. Op log on Kafka/Redpanda. Composite views in Redis. OpenSearch for discovery. Neo4j deferred to read-replica only if traversal load demands.Decided
- Entry 0242026-05-08Anti-flood posture for end-user submission spikesPower-tiered rate limits, per-triple pending-op throttle, isolated provider ingestion queue, daily consensus pass as natural shock absorber. Real-time consensus carved out per-Fact via lifecycle state when needed.Decided
- Entry 0252026-06-05Single apex domain and the OLN / Loredoor / Atlas splittheopenlore.net is the single primary domain. OLN is the neutral layer, Loredoor is the UGC product brand (not a domain), Atlas is the identity surface. Identity moves to its own repo, oln-atlas. data.* goes internal. Resolves G-031; supersedes the loredoor.com URLs in Entry 001.Decided
- Entry 0262026-06-05Network URL and namespace architecturePath-based URLs on one apex. Bare franchise slugs, canon as the default unmarked namespace, communities nested behind /g/, members at @handle, cross-franchise entities at reserved type paths like /person/. Extends and partly supersedes Entry 001.Decided
- Entry 0272026-06-05Users as graph entities, the Atlas customization ladder, and content isolationMembers are first-class graph entities with typed edges. Customization is a four-rung cascade, declarative-only on the main origin; raw HTML/widgets live on an isolated, PSL-listed user-content domain. Isolate by (trust x indexability).Decided
- Entry 0282026-06-05Atlas linktree — a verified external-reference pipelineAtlas profiles carry a linktree of external links. Ties to a franchise, entity, or Fact are optional-but-rewarded and must be proven about their target (AI-first, weighted). Verified ties enrich entity pages; links are admesh-ready but monetized later, per creator.Decided
- Entry 0292026-06-05The Fandom-killer thesis — a Fact-grounded, world-building wikiOLN's community wiki displaces Fandom by reimagining unstructured articles as Fact-grounded compositions over the Entity graph — adaptive to consume, owned by contributors. A gripes audit shows OLN's design already answers most top Fandom complaints; the wedge is the reimagined article/world-model, and the moat to crack is discoverability via AEO.Decided
- Entry 0302026-06-05Discoverability posture — citable, not trainable; a destination, not an answerResolves how AEO actually drives traffic and how OLN treats AI crawlers. AEO wins citation, not visits — so OLN plays two boards: be the most-cited source (supply) and own the world-model experiences a chat answer can't collapse (destination), with rights-holder partnerships breaking incumbency. And "AI bots" is split by class: allow citation crawlers (they attribute), block training crawlers (they launder contributor labor), and hold the structured graph — not the CC-BY-SA prose — in reserve as the licensable asset.Decided
- Entry 0312026-06-05Gamifying the graph — fun as a quality flywheel, tuned by A/BMaking structured contribution fun is the lever on G-057's make-or-break authoring friction. The decided principle: gamify accuracy, resolution, and completeness — never raw volume — so the fun mechanic is the data-quality flywheel, not its enemy. Lean on native graph mechanics over bolted-on points, put intrinsic impact ahead of extrinsic credits, and ship every component behind the Amplitude Experiment harness paired with a quality guardrail metric.Decided
- Entry 0322026-06-05Growing the embryos — bridging the civic layer to the productA system-wide gap analysis found the shipped product is a civic/governance doc-site whose primitives (annotations, reactions, profiles, event tracking) are embryos of decided-but-unbuilt product surfaces. The decision: bridge to product by growing those embryos rather than greenfielding, and build the connective tissue several decided systems silently assume — a unified Fact review/confirm queue, notifications, prose↔Fact linking, search signals, the experiment harness, and payment rails.Decided
- Entry 0332026-06-05No Gotchas — fail-closed source complianceCommunity source nomination (G-066) targets curated, authoritative sources (e.g. starwars.com for a Star Wars franchise), not random sites — and every source is governed by a fail-closed compliance posture: pull and archive its terms before ingest, monitor those terms daily, and auto-pause ingest the moment they change. A "No Gotchas" environment where compliance is continuous, not a one-time check.Decided
- Entry 0342026-06-07Memory Alpha is CC-BY-NC — rebuild natively, move the communityResearch found Memory Alpha is licensed CC-BY-NC 4.0 (non-commercial), which an ad-supported OLN cannot bulk-rehost. Decision: do not reuse the NC text commercially. Instead recruit the Memory Alpha community to OLN and rebuild Star Trek canon natively under OLN's license, using Memory Alpha only as a human-verified reference signal — bring the people, not the bytes.Decided
- Entry 0352026-06-13Entity facts are registry data, not renderer codeThe entity page rendered almost nothing for non-character types — a film showed one Performer and dropped its director, composer, box office, runtime, and cast — because the renderer's fact vocabulary (which keys are valid, their labels, their aliases) was hardcoded in page code and character-shaped. The facts existed in the data the whole time; the UI silently discarded any key it didn't recognize. Decision: the per-type schema registry is the single source of truth for valid predicates, labels, aliases, and display groups; the renderer derives its vocabulary from it (in-memory cached, reloads on change, read from Firestore). Adding a new fact type is now a registry edit, not a code change and deploy.Decided
- Entry 0362026-05-26Two-layer economics — the network self-funds first, communities are a backstopThere are two economic layers, not one. The network layer — the clean, centralized canonical pages built now — carries ads whose revenue goes to a network fund that must cover all network expenses on its own before anything is asked of communities. Communities (the modernized wiki-farm layer) carry their own ads into their own treasury; the network draws a percentage from those treasuries only as a backstop, when its own fund falls short. A revolving slush fund seeds new communities with repayable advances. Exact percentages and the recalculation engine are deferred until real per-franchise numbers exist.Decided
- Entry 0372026-06-05The contribution surface — a live editor, not wikitext, and never user codeThe CMS for Content and Community pages is a block editor you edit in place (TipTap / ProseMirror), not a WYSIWYG box and never wikitext. ProseMirror JSON is the source of truth; MDX is only a safe interchange format for export and diffing and is never compiled or evaluated. Pages render through a component allowlist, so user content cannot execute. Launch is presence + a soft single-writer lock, not real-time co-editing. Plugins and themes are marketplaces over a no-user-code substrate: a plugin configures an OLN-reviewed component, a theme is validated design tokens — arbitrary JavaScript waits for a sandbox built when demand proves it out.Decided
- Entry 0382026-05-27The Way — a Fact's type must be trusted before it enters the graphExtraction is fail-closed on type confidence. Before the pipeline pulls facts from an entity, it must be confident what *kind* of thing the entity is — and that confidence is highest when independent signals agree (a Wikidata type and the source infobox say the same thing). Entities whose type is corroborated clear the bar and auto-extract; entities with a single weak signal, or a conflict, wait for human validation rather than polluting the graph with mis-typed facts. Quality is enforced by code at the gate; humans supply judgment only where the signal is genuinely ambiguous.Decided
Founder’s Backlog
Questions the Creator has explicitly declined to pre-decide, deferred to the appropriate governing body once it exists. This is a feature, not an oversight. See the full backlog.
- B-001Fork thresholds and mechanics
- B-002Home contributors on Franchise Teams
- B-003Cross-franchise entity handling
- B-004Promotion / demotion criteria for indexed Network canonical pages
- B-005Rubric weight initialization (within-category)
- B-006Dormant Franchise handling
- B-007Procedural appeals on Arbiter rulings
- B-008Creator Home monetization mechanics